Welcome to our new website!
May 16, 2024

College Students: Can You Get Expelled for Protesting? Legal Advice for Activists

College Students: Can You Get Expelled for Protesting? Legal Advice for Activists

This episode focuses on the legal consequences of participating in protests as a college student. Attorney Bernie Brown offers guidance on how to avoid expulsion while making your voice heard.

This episode focuses on the legal consequences of participating in protests as a college student. Attorney Bernie Brown offers guidance on how to avoid expulsion while making your voice heard.

Transcript

0:00 Jesse L Hammonds: Coming up on this episode of the Healthy, Wealthy, and Wise podcast. In theory, if you know, if you're absolutely 100 percent sure that you didn't do anything wrong. You can respond to the questions, but generally lawyers say do not respond because most people talk themselves into a greater criminal culpability when they start answering questions. But to a parent, I would just advise the parent Welcome to the healthy, wealthy, and wise podcast with Dr. William T. Choctaw, MD, JD, where the doctor helps you unlock your full potential by equipping you with the tools and knowledge in the areas of health, wealth, and wisdom anchored in his experience.

0:44 Experience as a business executive, a physician surveyor for the joint commission, a former mayor, and over 50 years of experience as a general surgeon. You've got questions, he's got answers. So let's get started. Here's Dr. William t Choctaw, md, jd. So if, if, if you were to, to, to summarize, um, um, uh, again, let's go, go, go back to the hypothetical. You're invited to speak to the city council at UCLA and they, they, they, they're planning to have this demonstration for what, whatever issue they do, uh, they're going to have it for.

1:26 What, what, what general advice would, would, would you in summary sort of give them? Well. There, there's no precise advice, but generally I would say, first of all, set a time and a date and, and a location, a location. If the location is going to be on campus, I would limit the hours. I would, uh, and I would, uh, make sure that everybody understands if possible, the rules. Okay. That is, uh, that we're going to have a demonstration that we're not going to violate any laws. That we're going to leave at a certain time rather than because, you know, they set up encampments at UCLA and they were there overnight.

2:15 And that could theoretically go forever, you know. Right. And we're not going to obstruct operations or the business ongoings of the school. We're not going to interfere with anything. We're just going to go there. We're going to give our speeches. We're going to make our statements. We're not going to interfere with anybody. We're not going to use profanity toward anybody. We're going to be totally peaceful. We're going to tell everybody exactly our time limits. And we're going to let everybody know that we, our restrictions and everything, that we, our limitations, and that we're going to leave at a certain time, uh, and not over, overdo our, our welcome.

3:02 And, and could you And, and just in summary, because I want to make sure that I get all this, um, just, just read through your, your first four or five main, main topics and, and give me a summary to those. Uh, where are you talking about what rights to demonstrate, uh, do demonstrators have? Uh, when do you cross the line, go too far, just, just sort of like a summary for each one of those. Demonstrators, as we found in the Constitution of the United States, we have the right to free speech and the right to freedom of assembly. But, and so that's constitutionally protected. Right. So those rights are there, but they're subject to limitations.

3:42 And the limitations are if you violated any, any laws, or if you are on property where at some point the property owner decides that they no longer Want to give you permission to be there and they declare that you are trespassers and ask you to be removed So you cross the line generally when do you cross the line when you violate any laws? Okay, when you refuse to leave when being requested to leave If you're using out loud and unreasonable You're too loud. You're using profanity You're fighting You You're tearing up stuff, damaging property, and you've gone over the line.

4:32 And some of that is sort of common sense, you know, that you, you, yeah, that, that you, you have to be respectful, I guess, of the environment and those around you, but still make your point or give your opinion and that sort of thing. Yes, but the, they're actually, the, the rules are not clear cut and they're constantly. Uh, going through, shall we say, a metamorphosis. They're constantly changing. The Supreme Court is constantly, uh, frequently getting new cases. Got it. That's going on throughout our entire history of the nation where they would be receiving cases and being required and requested to interpret the law and the Constitution and to set the rules with regard to the Constitution.

5:18 What is permissible and what is not permissible, right? And, and so it sounds real beautiful to say, Oh, we have free speech. You know, we can criticize the government, right? Really? And yes, we can. Right. But it depends on how we do it and where we do it and when we do it. That determines whether it, uh, whether we. cross the line and go too far. And I think your comments about when you were in China and you asked, or you said, you know, do you have free speech? And they said, yeah, we can say anything as long as we don't criticize the government. Yes. And they were pretty serious about that.

6:00 Cause they said, they said, well, when you're in your own home, they said that sometimes there were like, I don't want to call them spies. But they would neighbor would rat out a neighbor, shall we say, if your neighbor heard you criticizing the government, they could report you to the government and you could get in trouble or get prosecuted based on someone saying they heard you, uh, saying things that were critical of the government. So, uh, you know, it's interesting to live in a free country where you can say things. It does create, uh, I think in the long run, a greater discussion and analysis ultimately leads to, uh, policies that, uh, are, are, are better for the nation.

6:54 Uh, I think down the road, but during the process, it can be disrupted. And I think the reason why Governments in other nations don't allow it. It's because they are free, afraid of the consequences in this nation. We learned how to voice our opinions, state our differences, and yet keep The, the nation together, you know, not fall to pieces, not turn it, not, not turn into a civil war. Exactly. So, so far we have, sometimes I wonder how long that will continue, I hope it will continue throughout all history.

7:41 Well, they, they call democracy, I think, an experiment, you know, so far our experiment has failed. I hope. But I think it will be tested as time goes on. Yes, looks like it. Uh, looks like we're coming up for a nice test in the next election. Yeah, yeah. Any other comments, Bernie, you want to share with us? No, I just want to say that you're doing a remarkable job. Thank you for having me on your podcast. It is a great contribution to the community for people to hear. Uh, your great words of wisdom, you know, I was, I keep having this nasal drip and congestion.

8:23 So I'm looking forward to your podcast, your podcast that you'll do on how to clear out my nasal. We'll certainly work on that. I'll get rid of this nasal drip and congestion. Well, it's called Springtime and Pollen, that's right. You're probably getting that ocean breeze anyway. Ocean breeze is everything, but you've done so many podcasts. Like I said before, you did that one on artificial intelligence, and I thought I'd never understand artificial intelligence, but you broke it down and made it understandable.

9:04 Well, the common man like me, the common person, we, we, we thank you also, as I said before, you know, that, that because particular with legal issue, because you are on the, the, the worked on the prosecutor's side, um, that that's a unique perspective, I think, uh, than, than most legal perspectives that one would get, certainly that I would get. And I think that's helpful. I mean, I think that that gives us extra knowledge, um, and, and with a certain honesty and openness to say, okay, these are your choices, A and B, but you need to be clearly aware of what those choices are and not be fooled by think that, well, you can do A and get away with it.

9:47 It's not that big a deal. It is a big deal. It is a big deal. And those choices are clear. And so you have to decide. Yeah, tough choices when you're in college and you want to fight for things, but then you've put in all these years and all this study and you don't want to get expelled. Exactly. Oh, no. And let me ask you, do most of these students get expelled? I mean, I don't think so. I think the vast majority of them do not get expelled. At my law school, when we put on our big demonstration, I didn't hear of anybody getting expelled. Well, there was. Oh, there are a couple of people that got, uh, got like suspended, shall we say, temporary, temporarily suspended or whatever, but no, generally not.

10:34 But I do believe, uh, that if you're charged with a more serious offense, like, you know, battery or assaulting an officer, fighting or something like that, the chances of getting expelled. go up significantly. You run the risk of expulsion. I heard that that at some of the colleges back east, they were considering expelling some of the students participated in the demonstration. If you were advising parents, um, let's say little Johnny called home and said, mommy, I'm in, I'm in jail because I was at a demonstration.

11:16 Well, what would you advise parents to do? Uh, They're in jail because of a demonstration? Well, most of these students that are in jail are generally cited out. That is, they go there, they get booked. They get. Released within 24 hours. It's usually they don't hold them in jail unless they've committed a more serious misdemeanor or something that arises to a felony. Uh, so usually they're going to get out and so usually you would tell them, you know, just Uh, don't, uh, you know, like lawyers always advise, don't talk, exercise your right to remain silent.

12:04 To remain silent. Okay. That's good advice. I want to, can you actually say that, you know, I, I, I, I, I choose not to speak until my attorney arrives. Oh yes. Absolutely. Absolutely. Absolutely. When you're being arrested there, you know, they have to give you a Miranda rights and advise you of your right to remain silent and tell you that anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law and on and on and on. You have to tell you that when they arrest you and then you can say, and then they'll start asking you questions, right? Right. And that's when you can say, well, I'm actually, you just told me I have the right to remain silent. So I'm going to remain silent. Now, in theory, if you know, if you're absolutely 100 percent sure that you didn't do anything wrong.

12:49 You can respond to the questions, but generally lawyers say do not respond because most people talk themselves into a greater criminal culpability when they start answering questions. But to a parent, I would just advise the parent, uh, obviously if the child is not going to get out of jail anytime soon, bail would have to be set. And I, as a parent, I would be trying to make bail so my kid could get out of jail. Be like, oh, okay, I'll make jail. But then, at some point, they would have to face my wrath. Exactly. You did what? You were tearing up what? You were, oh, you.

13:30 You painted on the administration door building. Why, you know, you don't have the right to vandalize their building. You know, you can't do that. You know, I'd be, you know, doing the parent thing. And I think for our audience, it's fair to say that I know you have at least two kids and I know one is a doctor and one is a lawyer. Is that right? Yes. Oh, so I think you, you, you did some things good. I got lucky and God blessed me. Well, but I, I think all of us, all of us want, want, want that type of luck and that's, yeah. Um, yeah, go ahead. Yeah. I was able to give my children a lot of good counseling because of my childhood.

14:15 Is that right? In what way? Well, I could say that, um, what happened to various children on my street. Right. I told him at a very young age. I said, okay, there was a guy down the street. His name was Joe. He, he was the king of the kids, but as he grew up at some point, he got hooked on heroin. And when he got hooked on heroin, he wound up in jail and then he died. And then I went down every child on the street because I could tell them each child's story. You know, there was, uh, Mr. Butler and, uh, Ricky Butler or, or Stanley Williams, Stanley Williams was a, uh, he was a good, smart kid, but now in his story, he got hooked on crack cocaine.

15:09 He, he wound up homeless. Wow. And, and so his story was a bad story, but then I had good stories. It was Daryl Goss and, and the Goss family, Goss brothers, what I'm, uh, they were both good kids. They worked really hard and one of them wound up being, uh, an accountant. One is a certified public accountant and the other one's a lawyer. Okay. Okay. So. You go down, oh man, I had a story for everybody, for all the kids. There was a kid who, across the street, uh, he, Tidwell, Orlando Tidwell, it's terrible, I'm naming names, a lot of these people are dead, so it won't, I can't be serious, but what happened to Orlando, he concocted this scheme to break into this, uh, tire, uh, The store, uh, on the corner, he was a teenager and so he went up on the roof and he entered at night.

16:16 They had, they had experienced several break ins, so they had hired a security guard. When a lender came down, entered the building through the ceiling to try to steal whatever he was going to try to steal, a security guard shot and killed him. Wow. Wow. So, I mean, you share all these stories with, I was able to share all these stories with my kids about success stories and stories of people who were not successful. And so then they could evaluate for themselves, you know, to some extent. How do you make sure as a parent that, that you get through to your kids, you know, because a lot of times as kids get older, you know, the last people they want to listen to a mom and dad type thing that says, well, you know, you're sort of old school and things have changed and blah, blah, blah.

17:12 How do you break through those barriers? Well, you know, kids are generally very intelligent. They're really smart and if you tell them, just say, okay, here are the logical consequences of your actions. You know, if you do this, this is what's going to happen to you. If you do this, you know, and if you do this, this is what can happen to you. And if you just explain to them and the beauty of it has been in certain cases where I said to them, If you do this, this and this and this will happen and they did it anyway.

17:53 And then the first thing happened and he said, Oh, and then the second thing happened. And by then they were like, okay, I'm going to stop doing it. If it's not, you know, it wasn't too late. Right. Right. They were able to see that. Oh, going down that road of conduct was going to lead to these consequences. Yeah. Right. And thus avoid those consequences. Uh, but clearly, there's no, uh, just precise way, because there's so many factors. I was into, to some degree, controlling who my kids hung out with.

18:34 Okay. Because their friends can really, will have a great influence on them. Right. So if they can hang around with good people and people who were good kids, doing good things, and positive, and achieving, and wanting to do the right thing. Now you don't always know what their friends are doing, but generally if they can hang out with positive, good friends, then that helps them. That helps them to be groomed as compared to hanging out. With thugs and gangsters and all of that. I still remember the day my son came home. I mean one day He was getting up to go to school And I I happened to be there before I go to work and I look And he had on these pants and they were bagging below his butt And I said, you know, usually thugs wear that kind of, you sure you wanna go to school with your pants like that?

19:34 You know, this was a thing. Right? Right. It was a thug gang thing. Right. I said, I don't, you know, it really doesn't look cool. I don't think you should do this. And, you know, do these gangsters and thugs. And, and they, they, that's who does that? Is that the way you Mm-Hmm. really wanna look, but I didn't tell 'em. No, you can't do it. Right, right. But you let him know that, that you were not supportive of it and, and he basically got the message that it wasn't, in my opinion, and he stopped. Okay, good. We did it that one day. I think he may have realized what he was doing and, and it didn't happen again. So is he the one that's now the lawyer?

20:15 He's the doctor. He's the doctor. Yeah, right. The lawyer was smarter. The girl, she was, she was smarter. We all make mistakes and growing up in my story, I'm reluctant to tell my story because I grew up in South L. A. and I was surrounded by gangs and drugs and All this all all of it going on and I hung out with a lot of guys and You know, I kept my mother had me going to Sunday school all the time all the time So that was good because that gives you a moral basis.

20:59 Yes Yeah Because in certain communities, there are, there are a lot of temptations and your friends are saying, oh, come on, man, this is good marijuana, you can try this stuff, me and you, you know, and, and just so many stories of stuff. There was a guy, that same guy, Joe Houston, we had a group of kids, a whole group of us. We had a club called Fisherman's Cool and we would all meet at Joe Houston's house in his garage and we were all cool and everything. But one day, see, I was a little younger so they didn't ask me to participate, but they decided that there was a local bar.

21:43 I mean, yeah, I think it's called Bar Boys Market, Boys Market. I don't know where he remembered us. Anyway, uh, they decided they were, they, they were going to go there and rob the market. Oh my goodness. The store, the grocery store. Right. These are, you know, young teenagers. Wow. And, but because I was only about 11 or 12, they said, you can't participate. But they let me hear all the stuff. They were planning it and all this. Right. And they went there and did it. Oh my goodness. And they all got caught and arrested. Of course. . You know, so I mean, there's all these influences around and I'm lucky to have gotten outta that. But you survived it.

22:24 I was surrounded by drugs and, and people who are committing crimes and all that kind of stuff. Right. So, and it just shows that even if you are in that environment growing up, that there's hope. You know, and then now you, you passed on that next generation. That would be at that next level. Yes. And I think a lot of judges take that into consideration, you know, my wife's a judge and I think, I think it's consideration because some, you know, there's some judges who say, Oh, you've been charged with this crime, blah, I'm throwing the book at you, go to prison, blah, you're going to be gone forever. There are others that say, okay, I'd see some hope in you. I think there's a chance, you know? So, and they might give you, you know, I'll give you a chance to reform and to get it right and to change your life and go in a different direction.

23:12 And so there's a lot of discretion where we can help people in their lives so that they can have successful. Happy, healthy, and wealthy lives. Indeed. And thank you so much, Bernie. Because I'll go. That's a good way to end it. We want everybody to be healthy, wealthy, and wise. We're talking about mentally, spiritually and physically, um, that health is more than just physical. But again, Barney, thank you again for your valuable information and your equally and more valuable time to share your words of wisdom with us.

23:54 And certainly anytime you have any other thoughts on any subject that you would like to share with us, just let us know that there's always time and a time slot and a platform available for you. Thank you so much. I appreciate it. All right. You have a terrific day. Take care. Bye bye. Thank you for listening to this episode of the Healthy, Wealthy, and Wise podcast with Dr. William T. Choctaw, MD, JD. Be sure to check out other great episodes covering areas of health, wealth, and wisdom at thwwp. com. And while you're there, be sure to check out the books, blogs, and other literature in your preferred format.

24:38 And don't forget to leave a comment. Review, subscribe, share and support the podcast. That's at t wwp.com. You've been listening to the Healthy Weather and Wise podcast with Dr. William t Choctaw, md, jd.

Related to this Episode

Balancing Activism and Academics: Strategies for Avoiding Expulsion

Introduction College students have a long history of participating in protests and political activism. From the civil rights movement to the Vietnam War protests, students have played a vital role in shaping the course of history. However, students…