Welcome to our new website!
April 22, 2024

Police Encounters: Communication and De-escalation Strategies

Police Encounters: Communication and De-escalation Strategies

Communication is key during police interactions. This episode offers tips for de-escalation and effective communication to ensure a safer and more positive outcome.

Communication is key during police interactions. This episode offers tips for de-escalation and effective communication to ensure a safer and more positive outcome.

Transcript

0:00 Dr William T. Choctaw: Uh, this is Dr. William T. Choctaw, and I will be your host today to the Healthy, Wealth Wise podcast. Um, we always like to go over our beliefs. We believe life is about being of service to other people. We believe knowledge is power. We believe leaders can change the world. And so, in essence, what we want to do for you, our audience, is to empower you With knowledge to make the world a better place. So welcome. Bernie. Bernie Brown, Esq: Hi. Hello there. How's it going? I want to talk to you today about what are your rights when dealing with the police? And what are their rights when dealing with you?

0:43 Do I have the right to refuse to answer questions? Obviously you can, but we mentioned license registration. I'm going to start going a little bit faster. Okay. Consent to allow them to search my car. Obviously the answer is generally no. You can if you want. There's nothing to say. You don't have to consent. You generally know. Yeah. Can the police keep me there for a prolonged period of time? They stop you for a traffic violation, and they want to keep you there, and they tell you, Oh, well, you know what? We have to bring the dogs. We're bringing a canine unit, and they'll be here in about 20 minutes. But while we're waiting, we'll just ask you a few questions.

1:24 We can talk while we're waiting. Report it said. No, no, no. You cannot. You have a prolonged, uh, detention while you're just citing a person. It has to be reasonable. You cite the person, you let them go and be done with it. You can't use that as a ruse to, uh, keep them there while you conduct other investigations to get them to admit to anything. Okay, sure. Yes, quickly. Can they search my vehicle? Yes, they can search it, pursue it to a warrant if they have a warrant to search and they can search it. If you give them consent, they can search your vehicle. If there's probable cause, uh, evidence of criminal activity that's inside the vehicle.

2:12 If there's anything in plain view that we discussed earlier. They can search it as we mentioned earlier, pursue it to an arrest, because when they arrest you, if the vehicle's there and they impound the vehicle, then when it gets to the station, they do an inventory search and impound search and whatever they find, boom, is admissible in the evidence. Got it. Now, they can search you if they have some reasonable suspicion that there are weapons in the vehicle. They can search you for work, search the vehicle if there's officer safety issues. Uh, As we mentioned earlier, they can search the glove compartment for a license and registration. Uh, now, and as we said earlier, illegally seized evidence may be thrown out.

2:58 Okay? Dr William T. Choctaw: Okay. Bernie Brown, Esq: That's pretty much it with regard to vehicles. We've discussed home, vehicles, and in public place. Now, the one last area we're going to talk about Is police use the force? Dr William T. Choctaw: Will police use the force? Bernie Brown, Esq: Yes. When can they use force on a person? Okay, Dr William T. Choctaw: got it. Bernie Brown, Esq: The police can use When can they use deadly force? Police can only use deadly force. When it is necessary in defense of human life, where there is an imminent threat of death or serious bodily injury to the officer or to others.

3:45 And they must stop using deadly force. Once the danger has stopped. Okay. If somebody's coming at you with a gun or that teenager we talked about had a gun turned out to be a replica, but I didn't know that. And the standard is whether a reasonable officer would in similar circumstances believe that he was justified in using force. It's the reasonable person standard. So if the kid is coming at you with a gun and you don't, it looks like a real gun, it turns out to be a fake gun and he points it at you. Now, then theoretically, the officer could theoretically shoot him.

4:29 Dr William T. Choctaw: Right now, Bernie Brown, Esq: on the other hand, in this particular video, when they showed it on the news, on the one you were talking about, the kid was saying something like, uh, you could hear him saying something like, it's not real. I'm going to, you know, it's not real officer. So yeah, does it get to the point where they, you're not justified in using deadly force? The question too becomes what is deadly force? Well, gun is deadly force. A knife is deadly force. Can a stick be deadly force? It becomes an interesting question. In a particular situation where when I was a young man and I saw the police officer shoot that, the guy, what happened was he was, he was stealing a car in South.

5:14 And so what happened was he was drove his vehicle. They said at an officer. In which event, his car became a deadly weapon, in which event they had, they contend we had the right to use deadly force to defend ourselves, because he was driving his car at us, and if he had hit us, he was using his car as a deadly Dr William T. Choctaw: weapon. What about the situations, um, at least if I'm familiar, if I'm correct, where the person is running away, they shoot him in the back. And say they were in fear of their life, but but the person is running away from them. How is that?

5:56 Bernie Brown, Esq: Acceptable there are some jurisdictions where they take the position that a fleeing felon, okay That they can apprehend a fleeing felon that they you can use deadly force, uh against a free fleeing, uh However, that's generally not the case that does not meet the standard of using uh, only that voice, which is necessary under the circumstances. And so ordinarily, that's what it's kind of embarrassing sometimes with the police officers. Cause a lot of times they're searching, they're, they're chasing some guy and they can't shoot him legally.

6:36 They cannot shoot him in the back. If they don't believe he has a deadly weapon. Uh, And so then they chase him, chase him and the officer is getting tired, but they can't shoot him in the back. If they do, Or shoot him during the process if they don't believe he has a weapon. So they have to pursue him and they have to use reasonable force to detain him. Reasonable force, which is just, you control him so that they can handcuff him. And that does not include Deadly force. Dr William T. Choctaw: Well, you know, I guess I, I've been watching too much law and order. I, I need to, I need to talk to professionals like you because they, it seems like on law and order, you know, you'll have this sort of chubby person who's chasing this guy and he can't catch him.

7:25 There's no way he's gonna catch him, so he just shoots him because he can't catch him. I mean, he, he , I mean, guys go civil, Bernie Brown, Esq: civil rights lawyers, jump all over those Dr William T. Choctaw: always that, right. Bernie Brown, Esq: If he's one. There are certain jurisdictions, states, because these laws can vary on some of these laws. Some of them are nationwide, but others are state to state. And there, there are certain states where a fleeing felon, if he's, if he's wanted for a deadly type of offense, you know, a serious and dangerous offense, they would allow the deadly force.

8:06 But, uh, Ordinarily, that's not the case, and certainly you're subjected to a suit if you start shooting somebody in the back. Lawyers love that. They'll be suing, suing, suing. So, uh, we talked about fleeing. The interesting point is like we mentioned earlier, you mentioned a fleeing suspect who's running away and he throws something. Um, uh. Yeah, Throw something he he discards the drugs the gun or whatever Well, he he loses all of his rights when she throws it away Dr William T. Choctaw: Okay, Bernie Brown, Esq: it's no longer in his basically in his control and discarded evidence is admissible in a state in a court of law.

8:55 Okay, he basically waves his right to challenge the search once he throws the contraband away. And we actually saw cases I could never believe this, but I actually saw these cases where the police report says. Well, we were standing right there. I detained him and he pulled a drug packet out of his pocket and threw it on the ground. And I'm thinking, who would be stupid enough to do that? But then they show you the video and there it is. The guy reaches in his pocket and tries to toss it to the side. Uh, uh. Dr William T. Choctaw: So how many years were you in the prosecutor's office?

9:35 I mean, I would say Bernie Brown, Esq: 29 years, Dr William T. Choctaw: 29 years, almost 30 years. I bet you saw everything. We Bernie Brown, Esq: saw a lot of stuff. We, you know, it's intriguing stuff. A lot of the things you see on television, they really do happen in the courts. I mean, people, defendants going crazy and trying to attack the judges. The only thing that doesn't really happen. Is that Perry Mason Dr William T. Choctaw: stuff? Bernie Brown, Esq: Don't the lawyer, all the lawyer stuff happens. It's just the defendant all of a sudden gets up and says, okay, I did it. Dr William T. Choctaw: Right. Bernie Brown, Esq: Every episode of Perry Mason. Dr William T. Choctaw: That's right. By the end of the hour.

10:17 Right. That doesn't happen. Interesting. Bernie Brown, Esq: We, I don't know how we're doing on time. Uh, we actually had a case too, where I mentioned earlier resisting delaying or obstructing an officer. And so we would see cases where, you know, I'm your buddy, so I see the police chasing you and I want to help Dr William T. Choctaw: you. Bernie Brown, Esq: So what happens is the police are chasing the guy and the guy, uh, his buddy runs up and bumps the police officer down so that he, so that his friend can get away from the police. Dr William T. Choctaw: Right. Bernie Brown, Esq: Well, guess what happened?

10:57 He gets arrested for bumping into people. Dr William T. Choctaw: Of course, he's interfering with the Bernie Brown, Esq: So, yeah, uh, the question, now you didn't ask this question, but here it comes. Okay. Can you use profanity? Dr William T. Choctaw: Oh, okay. Bernie Brown, Esq: When you're having an encounter with the police, can you give them the the finger? Well, you certainly common sense says don't do it. Dr William T. Choctaw: Okay, so it violates your common sense standards. Bernie Brown, Esq: Certainly don't do it. Now, is it legal? Can you give the police officer the finger? Probably, you know, you say free speech and free speech allow you to to use profanity.

11:40 But you're gonna piss that officer off. And if you say something that Rises to the level of what's called fighting words. Okay, gone too far. There's a way Dr William T. Choctaw: to do that. Yeah, Bernie Brown, Esq: there's certain insults that are so inflammatory on Dr William T. Choctaw: this, uh, Bernie Brown, Esq: that, uh, they rise to the level of what's called fighting words. In which event, uh, you've gone too far. So, uh, and then lastly, Dr William T. Choctaw: okay, Bernie Brown, Esq: searches in security zone. There are certain areas where you do not have virtually all these constant constitutionally protected rights.

12:25 And one of those main areas is, uh, an airport. Dr William T. Choctaw: Oh, Bernie Brown, Esq: okay. They don't have to have probable cause, reasonable suspicion. Oh, makes sense. They can just, you know, you got to go through that metal detector. You got to be searched. And if you don't like it, it's gone. And you have, you know, don't go to the airport. Dr William T. Choctaw: Okay, no, that makes sense. And then because it's a safety thing. I mean, it affects everybody. Bernie Brown, Esq: Yes, Dr William T. Choctaw: theoretically in the airport or using the airport. Bernie Brown, Esq: Yes. Dr William T. Choctaw: Okay. Same Bernie Brown, Esq: thing is true for courts in certain public buildings. Dr William T. Choctaw: Makes sense. Makes sense. Bernie Brown, Esq: I think that's all we have for today. Okay. Okay.

13:06 You know, Dr William T. Choctaw: I, I should, I should tell our podcast viewers what I think that's unique about Bernie. And one of the reasons why we have him to, to educate us is that he is a prosecutor. He's not a defense attorney. He, you know, he, he's the guy who's trying to make sure that if you commit a crime, Or if you, uh, are guilty of a transgression, that you pay for that. And I, I think, I think a lot of times we, we don't get, this is my opinion, we don't get the prosecutor's perspective. Uh, and I think what makes Bernie unique in my, in my judge, one, he's a good friend of mine and, and somebody I trust. But but he can give me a balanced evaluation of something.

13:50 I don't have to worry about, you know, one side or the other. He's going to tell me yes or no, up or down, black or white type thing. And so it allows us to look at the data, look at the facts, look at the environment or the circumstances in a balanced way and say, you know, you just didn't use common sense. When you were, when you were, you know, using all these, these, these words, whatever, whatever, whatever. And that just makes sense to me. And, and so my point is, I think, Bernie, that, that's, that's what you uniquely in my judgment bring to this podcast is your, your reflection and your experience in addition to who you are. You know, because I think that's that's that's important.

14:32 Go ahead. Bernie Brown, Esq: Thank you for that I really appreciate that and that brings to thought just a side issue a lot of people Sometimes it's like all those prosecutors are evil. They're so bad. Uh, it's terrible terrible terrible there against the people, you know There's a train of thought of that One of the things that I really loved about being a prosecutor is when we we get the cases And we review the cases. And many times, many times we look at the case and say, Oh, no, we're not prosecuting this case. We're throwing it out. It's not going to go forward. That's the discretion you have as a prosecutor. If you look at the case and you don't believe that, uh, that's that all the evidence is there.

15:15 If you believe that there's a reasonable doubt, as to whether the person committed the crime. If you believe that there's any dishonesty or irregularities, you can throw the case out. So, uh, that discretion was a wonderful thing. I really enjoyed that. And I really thank you for allowing me to be on your podcast. You like, I go back, you're the most brilliant person I know. Dr William T. Choctaw: Thank, thank you for sharing your valuable time with us. And I can tell you, and I'm going to stop watching law and order. I can tell you because the prosecutor is never the hero, you know, the defense attorney is the hero, you know, about Tom Cruise.

15:57 And I think about all the other. You know, defense attorneys to kill a marking bird and whatever, whatever, no one glorifies the prosecutor. Bernie Brown, Esq: That's a terrible job. Dr William T. Choctaw: So I'm absolutely delighted for you, uh, being willing to, uh, share your knowledge with us, to educate us, um, you know, because knowledge is power and the more we know, and the more we educated, then we know what to do and what, what, what not to do. to keep us healthy mentally and spiritually. Um, uh, so, so thank you again for all of this. Um, and, uh, any, any other final comments?

16:38 Bernie Brown, Esq: No, thank you very much. God bless you. Keep the, keep the, keep doing what you're doing because it's a great thing. It's very helpful. Dr William T. Choctaw: sir. Thank you, sir. And what we always like to say to ourselves and to our audience, be the change that you want to see in the world. Have a great day. Thank you.