Welcome to our new website!
April 22, 2024

Staying Safe During a Police Encounter

Staying Safe During a Police Encounter

Confused about how to act during a police interaction? Learn essential common-sense tips for staying safe and protecting your rights.
(https://www.cleburnelaw.com/know-your-rights-during-a-traffic-stopsearches-and-seizures-at-traffic-stop) offers pra...

Confused about how to act during a police interaction? Learn essential common-sense tips for staying safe and protecting your rights.

(https://www.cleburnelaw.com/know-your-rights-during-a-traffic-stopsearches-and-seizures-at-traffic-stop) offers practical tips for staying safe and minimizing stress during a police interaction.

Transcript

0:00 Dr. William T. Choctaw: Uh, this is Dr. William T. Choctaw, and I will be your host today to the Healthy, Wealth Wise podcast. Um, we always like to go over our beliefs. We believe life is about being of service to other people. We believe knowledge is power. We believe leaders can change the world. And so, in essence, what we want to do for you, our audience, is to empower you With knowledge to make the world a better place. So welcome. Bernie. Bernie Brown, Eqs: Hi. Hello there. How's it going? I want to talk to you today about what are your rights when dealing with the police? And what are their rights when dealing with you?

0:43 Can the police set up a stakeout and spy on my house through binoculars? And the answer to that is yes. If they're in a, if they're in a public place, let's say they park down the street. And they just they got their binoculars and they do this, by the way, just watch you every time you go in and out the house and who's going in and out the house. And Dr. William T. Choctaw: so how is that not harassment, but you know, because again, I'm a nervous the kind of person and if I see people watching me, who may be law enforcement that just terrifies me.

1:26 Bernie Brown, Eqs: Well, a lot of times they try to do it incognito. They don't work. They don't. They're not. They're trying to do it. So you don't see them. That's why they have these binoculars and a couple of hundred yards away or a hundred yards away, but it's perfectly legal for them to be anywhere they want to be. As long as they're in a public place, they can park and they can watch your house. They cannot, we're going to get to home searches next and home intrusions, but they cannot come in your house. Well, but here's the irony of it is at some point if they see something going on inside of your house and the way they do this is they would set up a case by saying yes, every 15 minutes somebody came to the house.

2:06 And, and they would come, they would stay there for, uh, two or three minutes, and then they would leave. And there was this constant traffic in and out of the house. And one time we saw somebody come, and they were standing out on the front porch, and we saw the person hand some money. To the to the person, you know, the homeowner and the homeowner hand up a small package to the person and then the person leave and this went on and on day and day. So what they're trying to do is establish probable cause that this guy is dealing drugs or that there's some kind of criminal activity going on in the house. And so they would Present that to a judge at some point, and the judge would have to make a determination as to whether there is sufficient. But Dr. William T. Choctaw: isn't it true in the post covid era that a lot of people have home businesses and they, you know, people may come to their homes to purchase, I don't know, different items that the homeowner may make.

2:58 Uh, and it's a legitimate business. Bernie Brown, Eqs: You've got that Juris Doctor, you, you really know that. You went to law school, you know, you know your stuff. No, no, no. Certainly, that would be the defense, absolutely. And that would be, theoretically, Conceivably likely a successful defense in many circumstances, uh, the way it works and we'll move right on since we're, we're approaching that subject. We'll move on to home searches. Okay. Okay. And so the question being, can they come and search your home or can they enter your home? And basically when there are certain reasons, certain legal justifications as to why they can or can not.

3:43 And the main one is if they get a warrant. Okay. And the way that works is they go to a judge or a magistrate and they say, Oh, your honor, we've been conducting a surveillance of this home. And this is what we've seen. Now the judge may, uh, this is before they even get to trying to get the search warrant at this point. And the judge may say, no, I'm not going to give you a search warrant on this. You know what? It could have just been, you know, just delivering food. I'm not going to sign up on a search warrant. Oh yes, this is, this is evidence of probable cause. And it's relevant evidence of criminal conduct, criminal activity that's ongoing at that location.

4:26 So I'm going to give you a search warrant, and then you can go search. Oh, those celebrities homes. You can search the Diddy home. Right. So, search warrants are another way. And here's an interesting thing. Now, we talked about how the students said that, uh, that they would allow a search of their person. There are cases where police just walk up to a house, knock on the door and say, Hey, how you doing? You know what? Uh, I would like, can, can I have permission to come in and search your house?

5:10 You know, there are people, if you say yes, like again, we're back there again, you waived your rights because then they don't need a warrant. They don't need any of the other reasons that I'm going to talk about later to come into your house. Once you say yes, you can come in and you can, you can search my house, you then you've given consent. So, um, but they can actually do that. They can knock on your door. And now here's the other thing they can do, too, which is there's what's called a plane view doctor, right? And that is they come and they knock on your door. And while they're on your porch, they look through the window. And if they look through the window and they see drug activity ongoing through the window, you know, they see you grabbing drugs and, and, and running to another room.

5:59 They hear the, the, the toilet flushing, you know, yeah. Then they can break into the home. It's called exigent circumstances and they can say, well, we saw through the window from the outside of the house. We saw this criminal activity in plain view, and therefore we were permitted to go in without a warrant and seize that property. So the plain view doctrine can apply. There's what's called exigent circumstances. Okay. There's another reason why they can come in and this is an interesting thing is if they get a 9 1 1 call and the person says, you know, and they have the location, they go there and they go to that location and they hear screams.

6:49 Oh, okay. Even if they don't get a 9 1 1 call, if they go to that location, somebody inside and say, yeah, then they can break into the house. To provide aid to a person who is maybe in distress. Dr. William T. Choctaw: So if they come to one's house and I don't want them to come in, I can say no. Bernie Brown, Eqs: Yes. Dr. William T. Choctaw: Absolutely. I can just say, no, thank you. Bernie Brown, Eqs: Absolutely. If they don't, you can say, where's your warrant? Dr. William T. Choctaw: Okay. So I should, I should say, do you have a warrant or whatever? That, that's, that's, that's a right I have as a, as a citizen. Bernie Brown, Eqs: Absolutely. Yes. And, but now, like I said, they can be superseded.

7:32 Right, by other circumstances. Activity going on. Okay. Okay. They have a, sometimes they can come to a house because they've received a call of a medical emergency, and a lot of times they'll show up at a house. They've received a call, the woman's calling saying, Oh, I'm having a heart attack. I think I'm having a heart attack. And then when they arrive at the house, they knock on the door and nobody opens the door. Nobody comes to the door. Dr. William T. Choctaw: So, so police come on those calls as compared to paramedics? Yeah. Bernie Brown, Eqs: Well, what happens is they can break into the house to render aid to a person. If they believe that there's a medical emergency, Nobody comes to the door. Nobody opens the door then they can say, okay Well, we got this radio call and we think there's a medical emergency and if it's a valid reasonable Belief that there's a medical emergency and they can break into the house to read to render medical aid Got it.

8:30 Dr. William T. Choctaw: Okay Bernie Brown, Eqs: So those are just some of the reasons uh As I mentioned earlier, any indication that there's ongoing criminal activity can serve as a valid basis. Uh, here's an interesting thing. They show up at the house, right? And suspect isn't there. They may have seen the suspect. But they want to search the house. So what do they do? They show up and the girlfriend's there. Dr. William T. Choctaw: Okay. That's Bernie Brown, Eqs: the girlfriend. Can we search the house? Now, if the girlfriend lives there, she can give, she can give authority to at least come in and search the, the general area of the house.

9:12 Dr. William T. Choctaw: Ah, okay. Bernie Brown, Eqs: Now, they, there, there are cases that go back and forth on whether she can give permission to search his room, his personal private areas. Maybe not, but at least the living room, the family room, the open areas, Habitat can give permission to search those areas. Okay. Now, as you've seen, as we saw in that Diddy case, they threw stuff. You know, the media stuff. They just throw it all over the place. They empty up . Dr. William T. Choctaw: Now, why did they do that? I mean, couldn't they just search and neatly stack it up against the wall?

9:53 What's up with that? Bernie Brown, Eqs: Yeah, that would be nice. . I just put the stuff back, fold it up and put it down. No, they just leave it thrown all over the floor and everywhere. It was just a mess. Dr. William T. Choctaw: So do they do that to sort of make a statement or intimidate or, or is that just individual? Bernie Brown, Eqs: I guess they do it because they can get away with it. I don't think it's an individual thing. I think that when they conduct the search, they know they don't have any, Any responsibility to, uh, put stuff back. So leave it the way it is. It's terrible, but it is, uh, that is the way it is. They can also arrest a person.

10:33 I'm sorry, search a home pursuant to arrest. If they have an arrest warrant and they go to a location to arrest the person, the person is there. They can search within his immediate arms reach. Of where he is arrested and do what's called a safety, uh, security sweep before they are read or after they arrest. They could just quickly go and look in other rooms to make sure that there are no other, there's no danger to them. Okay, that makes sense. While they're looking in those other rooms, if they see something they can then, then they can seize it and legally.

11:13 Got it. Okay. Okay. Oh, man. There's a lot of rooms out there. There are exceptions to every rule, pretty much. So that's pretty much it with regard to home searches. Obviously, there are people who are on probation and parole and they're subject to a search. They have search conditions. So, uh, it was written in their probation statements that police can come to your house and search your house, you know, it might be really okay. If they're on probation or parole, they may have certain conditions that allow the police to come and make those searches in which event, they can do that so long as it's not harassing. And that's another story for another time.

11:55 Uh, car stops. Now we move on to the biggie, car stops. Excuse me. Can police stop your vehicle for traffic violations? And the obvious answer to that is yes. You know, they can stop you for all kinds of traffic violations. They can stop you for speeding, they can stop you for, uh, problems with your car, your, your rear view bulb light, brake light doesn't work, whatever. Uh, they can obviously stop you for a DUI. And when they stop you, obviously, as we discussed earlier, they can ask you for your license and registration, but they can also ask you for proof of insurance.

12:39 And obviously they generally do the site and release, they'll write you a site. For whatever the violation may be, but if you do not have a license, uh, then they might not allow you to drive the vehicle away. They may keep the vehicle there, and then they might later impound the vehicle. We'll get to that a little bit later. And if they impound it, then it's subject to an inventory search when they impound it. So all the little nuances to get around to look into that. Okay. And once again, we get back to the same doctrine that we were talking about earlier. That lane view doctrine.

13:20 If they come up to your car and they're stopping you for some type of traffic violation, an illegal lane change, you ran a stop sign. And when they walk up to your car, they stop you, and they look through the window, and they see a big vial of, Of cocaine or whatever in in your backseat. Now they can search the vehicle because in plain view while they were outside of the vehicle, they saw contraband. Illegal substances inside the vehicle. So that gives them probable cause and reasonable suspicion to search the vehicle. Dr. William T. Choctaw: If your car windows are excessively tenant, can they stop and search you? Bernie Brown, Eqs: Ah, now there becomes an interesting issue.

14:00 A lot of officers used tempting as a basis for detaining a suspect and There are a lot of laws on that. And the laws basically, basically, in its most simplistic form say if the officer cannot see the You can't see inside of your vehicle because the tent of your vehicle is so dark that they can't see inside, then they could theoretically stop you and cite you for that. Okay. And in which event they would have to ask you to roll down your window, in which event, they could see inside and if they saw any contraband obviously they could seize it. Otherwise, they could write you a citation for that, and by that time they can ask you For your license and registration.

14:46 Now, the interesting thing in here gets a juicy one. If you don't have a license and registration, they can go inside your glove compartment and search for your license or registration. Okay. Yeah. They can open your glove compartment or they can look under the seat and try to find your license and registration. And the same thing applies. Uh, with regard to your wallet. If you're in a public place, I forgot to mention that earlier, you don't have identification. There are some cases that say they can retrieve your wallet out of your pocket to try to search for your identification. And if they find anything while they're doing that, then that can be admissible in a court of law is against you.

15:35 So as all of these different little rules, they can go in the glove compartment to search for, as we said, for your license and registration, search your wallet. Uh, Dr. William T. Choctaw: let me ask a quick question. I remember that there is a actually Byron, who's a good friend of mine. He's a law enforcement officer in my Sunday school class, and he was made a comment. He said, if you're ever if you're driving your car, let's say you're coming from a party or a dinner and the people in the backseat. Um, he said that when, when, if the police stop you, you should immediately roll down every single window and put your hands up or on the wheels or, uh, so the, so the police can see them.

16:21 That, that you should just do it automatically. Don't, don't wait to be asked or whatever. Do you think that's reasonable or do you think that's sort of overreacting? Bernie Brown, Eqs: But that's the common sense. That's back to the common sense. Okay. Okay. You don't have to do that. But the police officers approaching you don't want them to be mistaken. Oh, I thought I saw a gun. Oh, I thought I saw him reach for something. Oh, man. It's better to get clearance before you reach for anything. Like take, for instance, if you're going to reach for the glove compartment. Right. Before you do that, if the officer's outside your view, you say, Officer, my registration is in the glove compartment. May I reach into the glove compartment to recover it?

17:02 Okay. Don't just go reaching in there because if you go reaching in there yourself, they might say, Oh, I thought it was going to happen. Dr. William T. Choctaw: Right, right. So, so that would fall within common sense that you just do, Bernie Brown, Eqs: but theoretically, you're not required to roll down all your windows. Dr. William T. Choctaw: Okay. Bernie Brown, Eqs: And, and you, you know, a lot of times the police will come up to you and they've. Uh, they keep in mind now all the police officers almost at least here in the L. A. County area and virtually many other jurisdictions. Almost all of them now have what called body cams, Dr. William T. Choctaw: right? Bernie Brown, Eqs: And they have it's either on their chest or it's on their head helmet or whatever. And it's a little camera and it starts recording everything that's going on during the traffic encounter during the encounter with the police.

17:49 And sometimes they don't turn it on there. Many, uh, jurisdictions are required to turn it on automatically whenever they stop somebody or detain somebody Dr. William T. Choctaw: in California. They're required to turn it on Bernie Brown, Eqs: in California locally. I think they did recently. I'm not absolutely certain, but I think they did recently pass a section that says they are required. Automatically activated, uh, years ago. Well, a few years ago when they were first rolling them out, they were set so that they would automatically come on when they're when their siren came on. Got it. Got to stop. And when they had an encounter, they would With the police officer, um, when, with a civilian, but they had a button, they all had a button where they could turn it off.

18:35 Dr. William T. Choctaw: Okay. Bernie Brown, Eqs: And they used to do that sometimes. The other thing that used to happen sometimes is a little bit off the subject is that they would write a police report and then we would see The video of it and it would be inconsistent. This used to happen So I'd say one thing in the police report and you look at the video and you say wait a minute That's not what happened here There's no there's no he's not swagging or he's not staggering he's not sweared slurred speech His eyes didn't look blitz bloodshot or watery So sometimes but so the video cameras are helpful and they are helpful to the officers, too Okay.

19:23 Dr. William T. Choctaw: Okay. They show, Bernie Brown, Eqs: they can show the suspect being unruly, going for a weapon. Video cameras are, can be a a, a great useful too. Now, the interesting thing is when the police come up to you, can they order you outta the vehicle? Dr. William T. Choctaw: Okay? Bernie Brown, Eqs: And the answer is yes. Okay. You are, if it is for officer safety, if they tell you driver and passenger exit the vehicle, you have to exit. If they tell you, remain in the vehicle. If they say do not exit the vehicle, you have to comply with that command. Now, obviously as we said earlier they may They may require you to produce your license.

20:03 I've said that several times Do they have to tell you why you are being stopped? The answer in many jurisdictions is yes, certainly most all jurisdictions have a requirement that if the police arrest you They have to tell you why they are placing you under arrest Okay. And so you can say, officer, why are you arresting me? And you can also say, why are you stopping me? They, in most jurisdictions, they are required to answer that question and to tell you why you are being detained. Uh, certainly while you are stopped in your vehicle, once again, they can start asking you questions.

20:45 And then once again, they can start asking you, as we mentioned earlier, they can ask you trick questions. To try to get you to admit to things, okay. Or to, uh, yeah, to admit that you have weapons or commit or admit that you did something wrong. Uh, do they have to have a re Do the police have to have a reason to stop you? Uh, yes. They can't just stop you from nothing. They can't, just, the law requires that police can't just stop and detain you in your vehicles. for no reason. They have to have some articulable articulable reason, uh, to believe that and it's under a reasonable officer standard.

21:30 You committed some form of a misdemeanor infraction or a felony offense before they can stop you. And as we indicated earlier, once they do stop you, they can conduct a pat down search. of your person and your body. Okay. Question. What are the possible reasons officers can stop me? What they can use to stop me in my vehicle? Well, just as examples. They stop people for erratic driving. You know, they say you were swerving. I was with a, uh, on a ride along with a seat, a CHP officer once we're sitting in the back seat. And these guys are really good. I have to give it to him. Because what he said was, Oh, man, he was weaving it within the road.

22:13 And he was kind of swaying outside of the lane. And I'm looking, it's nighttime. I'm like, I didn't see that. So I'm going to pull him over. So he pulled the guy over. And sure enough, the guy, when he gets out the car, he's drunk as a skunk. I'm like, really, really good observation. They can pull you over if you're texting. If some kind of way, if they could smell marijuana, they can do that. They can pull you over, obviously, for any traffic violations. They can pull you over if they have a police report of criminal activity. They can pull you over if you have an outstanding warrant.

22:55 Uh, as we indicated earlier, they can pull you over for what's called furtaconda. Dr. William T. Choctaw: Okay. Bernie Brown, Eqs: And that gets into what you were talking, sweating, but it's got to be more than just sweating and being nervous. Okay. Got to be some physical action that alerts them to think that you've committed a crime, something beyond just sweating. Uh, we, you mentioned tinted windows, if they're a certain degree of tint, they can pull you over. If it's too dark, if the windows are too dark, then obviously, so Dr. William T. Choctaw: there really is no standard, no industry standard on tinning. Bernie Brown, Eqs: Um, there are actually in the state of California, they're actually very detailed standard.

23:36 Really? Okay. We'd be here for a while and we went through all of them. But the basic, the basic premise is. And it's not the obviously not the factory tent that came with the vehicle, right? The tent is so dark that officers cannot see inside the vehicle. Dr. William T. Choctaw: So this is additional tent added to the factory tent? Bernie Brown, Eqs: Yes. Dr. William T. Choctaw: Oh, okay. Okay. Bernie Brown, Eqs: And that gives them a basis to stop and theoretically, Site you now what happens is we used to see cases where they would stop a person for tenant windows But the tent was not dark enough to justify the stop Dr. William T. Choctaw: Got it.

24:17 Bernie Brown, Eqs: So, that results in the whole thing being thrown out. Because if the tint is not dark enough, then first, if they're going to cite you for having illegally tinted windows, that doesn't apply, and if they fine anything for, during the course of, of, of detaining you, like drugs or anything, then that gets thrown out because the stop itself was not valid. Dr. William T. Choctaw: Fruit of the poisonous tree. Great. It surfaces every now and then. Bernie Brown, Eqs: It's coming back. It's coming back. Oh, that's great. sir. Dr. William T. Choctaw: sir.

24:58 sir. And what we always like to say to ourselves and to our audience, be the change that you want to see in the world. Have a great day. Thank you.